It has certainly been asserted that Onyx is recessive to Dry Olive, but what Rheaven says makes sense to me.
Kayla Wrote:If Onyx is dominant to Dry Olive than Onyx is from Papa, Dry Olive hidden is from Mama.
But couldn't it be if Onyx is recessive to Dry Olive, than you have Onyx hidden from Mama and Onyx passed from Papa?
So in this case it would be helpful to go further back up Alumit's pedigree and see something about timing. Would it even be possible for Alumit's ancestors to be hiding Onyx? One would have to look and see how the Dry Olive got put into the line and if there was an opportunity for another recessive eye to have passed into the line at the same time.
Or one could just move forwards with more breedings and proofs from different cats.