RE: KittCatS! Halloween Custom Collar Contest - results!
No. I see one had 6 and the other 7. Perhaps there was a typo in the OP which has been corrected.
But, OK, I see where you're coming from.
Could you have placed First or Second Place? No. Not possible.
Should you have been the SOLE Third Place winner, No. Not possible.
Is it possible that KittyCatS made an error and you should have been in a three-way tie for Third Place? Yes: if we assume a three-way tie is allowed.
But, since we're dealing with assumptions here, we simply need assume the rule "No more than two entrants in may share a tie," and you're stuck at no better than Fourth Place.
So, OK, it's up to KittyCatS to say if they made a mistake and you should have shared in Third Place, or if they forgot to mention that no more than two entrants may share a prize.
The easiest path is to say no more than two may share a prize and be done with the entire subject.
|