I sure wish we could get our cats back from menagerie after a few months i miss some of mine and I want to turn them in to pets
You can if you use the right kind of magic bottle from the mainstore.
I think it is still for free and can be used for a few cats only, but will let you get a few back =)
The orange menagerie bottle Minx is talking about has been taken away I believe? And if it hasn't it only works for cats sent in before februari...uhm.. 2011? or something, years and years ago at the least